Rules-of-thumb for predicting air-entry value of disturbed sands from particle size

Toshihiro Sakaki, Mitsuru Komatsu, Manabu Takahashi

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

With the goal of finding empirical direct relationships between the air-entry values (AEV) and characteristic particle diameters (i.e., d 10, d20, d30, d90,) determined from the particle-size distribution, we examined the AEV values for a variety of disturbed sands. It was found that the AEVs were, in general, strongly correlated to the characteristic diameters. The correlation was more distinct for uniform sands with uniformity coefficient of 2 or smaller. For those with larger uniformity coefficient values, the AEVs were highly correlated to smaller characteristic particle sizes d10 to d50 but less with larger characteristic particle sizes, d60 to d90. For all the sands examined in this study, the AEVs showed the least scatter when plotted against d30. The large particles do not necessarily control the AEVs because the pores between the large particles are often filled with smaller particles. The following best-fit power functions with respect to the frequently used characteristic particle diameters were found to have high r2 values; AEV = 8.2 d30-0.99and AEV =9.5 d50 -1.05(with AEV in cm and d in mm). The exponent close to -1 in both relationships confirms a strong "inverse" proportionality. The effective pore diameter, de′, estimated from the AEVs agreed closely with the mean pore diameters measured with mercury porosimetry and X-ray micro-tomography. All these findings suggest that the AEVs are strongly controlled by the particle sizes which determine the mean pore size, and that the capillary rise theory is applicable in terms of the effective pore diameter. Finally, easy-toimplement rule-of-thumb expressions, AEV [cm] = 8/d 30[mm] and AEV [cm] =10/d50[mm] were proposed with some limitations for a quick but reasonably accurate prediction of the AEV.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)454-464
Number of pages11
JournalSoil Science Society of America Journal
Volume78
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

particle size
sand
air
micro-computed tomography
capillarity
particle size distribution
mercury
tomography
particle
prediction

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Soil Science

Cite this

Rules-of-thumb for predicting air-entry value of disturbed sands from particle size. / Sakaki, Toshihiro; Komatsu, Mitsuru; Takahashi, Manabu.

In: Soil Science Society of America Journal, Vol. 78, No. 2, 2014, p. 454-464.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{cad5e5477d6747ecaf197f33b09acf0e,
title = "Rules-of-thumb for predicting air-entry value of disturbed sands from particle size",
abstract = "With the goal of finding empirical direct relationships between the air-entry values (AEV) and characteristic particle diameters (i.e., d 10, d20, d30, d90,) determined from the particle-size distribution, we examined the AEV values for a variety of disturbed sands. It was found that the AEVs were, in general, strongly correlated to the characteristic diameters. The correlation was more distinct for uniform sands with uniformity coefficient of 2 or smaller. For those with larger uniformity coefficient values, the AEVs were highly correlated to smaller characteristic particle sizes d10 to d50 but less with larger characteristic particle sizes, d60 to d90. For all the sands examined in this study, the AEVs showed the least scatter when plotted against d30. The large particles do not necessarily control the AEVs because the pores between the large particles are often filled with smaller particles. The following best-fit power functions with respect to the frequently used characteristic particle diameters were found to have high r2 values; AEV = 8.2 d30-0.99and AEV =9.5 d50 -1.05(with AEV in cm and d in mm). The exponent close to -1 in both relationships confirms a strong {"}inverse{"} proportionality. The effective pore diameter, de′, estimated from the AEVs agreed closely with the mean pore diameters measured with mercury porosimetry and X-ray micro-tomography. All these findings suggest that the AEVs are strongly controlled by the particle sizes which determine the mean pore size, and that the capillary rise theory is applicable in terms of the effective pore diameter. Finally, easy-toimplement rule-of-thumb expressions, AEV [cm] = 8/d 30[mm] and AEV [cm] =10/d50[mm] were proposed with some limitations for a quick but reasonably accurate prediction of the AEV.",
author = "Toshihiro Sakaki and Mitsuru Komatsu and Manabu Takahashi",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.2136/sssaj2013.06.0237n",
language = "English",
volume = "78",
pages = "454--464",
journal = "Soil Science Society of America Journal",
issn = "0361-5995",
publisher = "Soil Science Society of America",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rules-of-thumb for predicting air-entry value of disturbed sands from particle size

AU - Sakaki, Toshihiro

AU - Komatsu, Mitsuru

AU - Takahashi, Manabu

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - With the goal of finding empirical direct relationships between the air-entry values (AEV) and characteristic particle diameters (i.e., d 10, d20, d30, d90,) determined from the particle-size distribution, we examined the AEV values for a variety of disturbed sands. It was found that the AEVs were, in general, strongly correlated to the characteristic diameters. The correlation was more distinct for uniform sands with uniformity coefficient of 2 or smaller. For those with larger uniformity coefficient values, the AEVs were highly correlated to smaller characteristic particle sizes d10 to d50 but less with larger characteristic particle sizes, d60 to d90. For all the sands examined in this study, the AEVs showed the least scatter when plotted against d30. The large particles do not necessarily control the AEVs because the pores between the large particles are often filled with smaller particles. The following best-fit power functions with respect to the frequently used characteristic particle diameters were found to have high r2 values; AEV = 8.2 d30-0.99and AEV =9.5 d50 -1.05(with AEV in cm and d in mm). The exponent close to -1 in both relationships confirms a strong "inverse" proportionality. The effective pore diameter, de′, estimated from the AEVs agreed closely with the mean pore diameters measured with mercury porosimetry and X-ray micro-tomography. All these findings suggest that the AEVs are strongly controlled by the particle sizes which determine the mean pore size, and that the capillary rise theory is applicable in terms of the effective pore diameter. Finally, easy-toimplement rule-of-thumb expressions, AEV [cm] = 8/d 30[mm] and AEV [cm] =10/d50[mm] were proposed with some limitations for a quick but reasonably accurate prediction of the AEV.

AB - With the goal of finding empirical direct relationships between the air-entry values (AEV) and characteristic particle diameters (i.e., d 10, d20, d30, d90,) determined from the particle-size distribution, we examined the AEV values for a variety of disturbed sands. It was found that the AEVs were, in general, strongly correlated to the characteristic diameters. The correlation was more distinct for uniform sands with uniformity coefficient of 2 or smaller. For those with larger uniformity coefficient values, the AEVs were highly correlated to smaller characteristic particle sizes d10 to d50 but less with larger characteristic particle sizes, d60 to d90. For all the sands examined in this study, the AEVs showed the least scatter when plotted against d30. The large particles do not necessarily control the AEVs because the pores between the large particles are often filled with smaller particles. The following best-fit power functions with respect to the frequently used characteristic particle diameters were found to have high r2 values; AEV = 8.2 d30-0.99and AEV =9.5 d50 -1.05(with AEV in cm and d in mm). The exponent close to -1 in both relationships confirms a strong "inverse" proportionality. The effective pore diameter, de′, estimated from the AEVs agreed closely with the mean pore diameters measured with mercury porosimetry and X-ray micro-tomography. All these findings suggest that the AEVs are strongly controlled by the particle sizes which determine the mean pore size, and that the capillary rise theory is applicable in terms of the effective pore diameter. Finally, easy-toimplement rule-of-thumb expressions, AEV [cm] = 8/d 30[mm] and AEV [cm] =10/d50[mm] were proposed with some limitations for a quick but reasonably accurate prediction of the AEV.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84901812346&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84901812346&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.2136/sssaj2013.06.0237n

DO - 10.2136/sssaj2013.06.0237n

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84901812346

VL - 78

SP - 454

EP - 464

JO - Soil Science Society of America Journal

JF - Soil Science Society of America Journal

SN - 0361-5995

IS - 2

ER -