Extra-basinal fluid infiltration, mass transfer, and volume strain during folding: Insights from the Idaho-Montana thrust belt

David J. Anastasio, Gray Edward Bebout, James E. Holl

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

10 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Finite strain and geochemical variations along strain gradients were used to study cleavage development in carbonates in the Lost River Range, Idaho. Deformation accommodating layer-parallel shear was partitioned into thin deformation zones during folding of Willow Creek anticline. Cleavage intensity is strong to very strong in deformation zones and weak in surrounding rocks. Strain magnitudes range from ēS=0.32 (1:15:0.93:0.73; x, y, z, principal axes of strain) outside, to ēS,=0.64 (1.29:0.80:0.52) inside, deformation zones. We found a positive linear correlation between strain, cleavage development, and negative dilation. Volume loss, at a cubic centimeter scale, ranges from 12 percent to 49 percent. Cleavage selvages are depleted in Ca and 18O and enriched in other elements relative to microlithons and less deformed protolith carbonates. Mass-balance considerations indicate that cleavage was formed by incongruent pressure solution leading to a passive concentration of less soluble components during Ca loss and metasomatic additions of Si, Al, and K to produce authigenic clay minerals in selvages. Data for the Willow Creek locality and elsewhere in the Lost River Range (Davidson and others, 1998), Pioneer Mountains, and the Tendoy Range (Bebout and others, 2001), show that across the Sevier orogen, fluid infiltration was heterogeneous at centimeter-kilometer scales and resulted from positive feedback between deformation and far-traveled surficial fluids. Metasomatic strain softening enhanced deformation zone development, which generated increased permeability as the thrust belt evolved from a porosity-based closed system to a discontinuity-based open system. Increased fluid infiltration and isotopic exchange was associated with volume loss, increasingly prolate strains, and crystallization of clays, to produce the cleavage selvages. Mass transfer was accommodated by diffusion early and advection later in the deformation history. Mesoscopic structures (deformation zones, faults, veins) focused fluid flow and were kinematically related to larger-scale structures (faults, faultrelated folds). The inferred addition of surficial fluids to depths of > 7 kilometers in the thrust belt implies a fluid regime involving significant topographically driven recharge. Deformed whole-rocks and microsamples are lower in δ18O than undeformed samples which have 0- and C-isotope compositions similar to those of marine carbonates. Veins are even lower in δ818OV-SMOW, with minimum values of ∼ +5 permil reflecting penetration of the crust by ocean-derived precipitation with δ18O near to somewhat lower than 0 permil (range of -7.5 to +2.5‰ calculated for H2O in equilibrium with these veins). The inferred penetration, into the thrust belt, of nearshore meteoric waters is consistent with proximity to the reconstructed Western Interior Seaway. Later fluid infiltration locally lowered the δ18O of carbonates even further, based on the O-isotope compositions of veins related to younger compressional deformation and to the onset of crustal-scale extension in the Eocene. This progression toward lowered δ18O of the surficial waters is compatible with the retreat of the seaway during emergence of the thrust wedge and Paleogene extension, uplift, and subaerial volcanism.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)333-369
Number of pages37
JournalAmerican Journal of Science
Volume304
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2004
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

folding
mass transfer
infiltration
thrust
cleavage
fluid
carbonate
penetration
isotope
authigenic mineral
pressure solution
dilation
meteoric water
anticline
protolith
softening
river
rock
Paleogene
fluid flow

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Earth and Planetary Sciences(all)

Cite this

Extra-basinal fluid infiltration, mass transfer, and volume strain during folding : Insights from the Idaho-Montana thrust belt. / Anastasio, David J.; Edward Bebout, Gray; Holl, James E.

In: American Journal of Science, Vol. 304, No. 4, 04.2004, p. 333-369.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{6bc6129f145847d4a1cb61c54d620f84,
title = "Extra-basinal fluid infiltration, mass transfer, and volume strain during folding: Insights from the Idaho-Montana thrust belt",
abstract = "Finite strain and geochemical variations along strain gradients were used to study cleavage development in carbonates in the Lost River Range, Idaho. Deformation accommodating layer-parallel shear was partitioned into thin deformation zones during folding of Willow Creek anticline. Cleavage intensity is strong to very strong in deformation zones and weak in surrounding rocks. Strain magnitudes range from ēS=0.32 (1:15:0.93:0.73; x, y, z, principal axes of strain) outside, to ēS,=0.64 (1.29:0.80:0.52) inside, deformation zones. We found a positive linear correlation between strain, cleavage development, and negative dilation. Volume loss, at a cubic centimeter scale, ranges from 12 percent to 49 percent. Cleavage selvages are depleted in Ca and 18O and enriched in other elements relative to microlithons and less deformed protolith carbonates. Mass-balance considerations indicate that cleavage was formed by incongruent pressure solution leading to a passive concentration of less soluble components during Ca loss and metasomatic additions of Si, Al, and K to produce authigenic clay minerals in selvages. Data for the Willow Creek locality and elsewhere in the Lost River Range (Davidson and others, 1998), Pioneer Mountains, and the Tendoy Range (Bebout and others, 2001), show that across the Sevier orogen, fluid infiltration was heterogeneous at centimeter-kilometer scales and resulted from positive feedback between deformation and far-traveled surficial fluids. Metasomatic strain softening enhanced deformation zone development, which generated increased permeability as the thrust belt evolved from a porosity-based closed system to a discontinuity-based open system. Increased fluid infiltration and isotopic exchange was associated with volume loss, increasingly prolate strains, and crystallization of clays, to produce the cleavage selvages. Mass transfer was accommodated by diffusion early and advection later in the deformation history. Mesoscopic structures (deformation zones, faults, veins) focused fluid flow and were kinematically related to larger-scale structures (faults, faultrelated folds). The inferred addition of surficial fluids to depths of > 7 kilometers in the thrust belt implies a fluid regime involving significant topographically driven recharge. Deformed whole-rocks and microsamples are lower in δ18O than undeformed samples which have 0- and C-isotope compositions similar to those of marine carbonates. Veins are even lower in δ818OV-SMOW, with minimum values of ∼ +5 permil reflecting penetration of the crust by ocean-derived precipitation with δ18O near to somewhat lower than 0 permil (range of -7.5 to +2.5‰ calculated for H2O in equilibrium with these veins). The inferred penetration, into the thrust belt, of nearshore meteoric waters is consistent with proximity to the reconstructed Western Interior Seaway. Later fluid infiltration locally lowered the δ18O of carbonates even further, based on the O-isotope compositions of veins related to younger compressional deformation and to the onset of crustal-scale extension in the Eocene. This progression toward lowered δ18O of the surficial waters is compatible with the retreat of the seaway during emergence of the thrust wedge and Paleogene extension, uplift, and subaerial volcanism.",
author = "Anastasio, {David J.} and {Edward Bebout}, Gray and Holl, {James E.}",
year = "2004",
month = "4",
language = "English",
volume = "304",
pages = "333--369",
journal = "American Journal of Science",
issn = "0002-9599",
publisher = "Yale University",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Extra-basinal fluid infiltration, mass transfer, and volume strain during folding

T2 - Insights from the Idaho-Montana thrust belt

AU - Anastasio, David J.

AU - Edward Bebout, Gray

AU - Holl, James E.

PY - 2004/4

Y1 - 2004/4

N2 - Finite strain and geochemical variations along strain gradients were used to study cleavage development in carbonates in the Lost River Range, Idaho. Deformation accommodating layer-parallel shear was partitioned into thin deformation zones during folding of Willow Creek anticline. Cleavage intensity is strong to very strong in deformation zones and weak in surrounding rocks. Strain magnitudes range from ēS=0.32 (1:15:0.93:0.73; x, y, z, principal axes of strain) outside, to ēS,=0.64 (1.29:0.80:0.52) inside, deformation zones. We found a positive linear correlation between strain, cleavage development, and negative dilation. Volume loss, at a cubic centimeter scale, ranges from 12 percent to 49 percent. Cleavage selvages are depleted in Ca and 18O and enriched in other elements relative to microlithons and less deformed protolith carbonates. Mass-balance considerations indicate that cleavage was formed by incongruent pressure solution leading to a passive concentration of less soluble components during Ca loss and metasomatic additions of Si, Al, and K to produce authigenic clay minerals in selvages. Data for the Willow Creek locality and elsewhere in the Lost River Range (Davidson and others, 1998), Pioneer Mountains, and the Tendoy Range (Bebout and others, 2001), show that across the Sevier orogen, fluid infiltration was heterogeneous at centimeter-kilometer scales and resulted from positive feedback between deformation and far-traveled surficial fluids. Metasomatic strain softening enhanced deformation zone development, which generated increased permeability as the thrust belt evolved from a porosity-based closed system to a discontinuity-based open system. Increased fluid infiltration and isotopic exchange was associated with volume loss, increasingly prolate strains, and crystallization of clays, to produce the cleavage selvages. Mass transfer was accommodated by diffusion early and advection later in the deformation history. Mesoscopic structures (deformation zones, faults, veins) focused fluid flow and were kinematically related to larger-scale structures (faults, faultrelated folds). The inferred addition of surficial fluids to depths of > 7 kilometers in the thrust belt implies a fluid regime involving significant topographically driven recharge. Deformed whole-rocks and microsamples are lower in δ18O than undeformed samples which have 0- and C-isotope compositions similar to those of marine carbonates. Veins are even lower in δ818OV-SMOW, with minimum values of ∼ +5 permil reflecting penetration of the crust by ocean-derived precipitation with δ18O near to somewhat lower than 0 permil (range of -7.5 to +2.5‰ calculated for H2O in equilibrium with these veins). The inferred penetration, into the thrust belt, of nearshore meteoric waters is consistent with proximity to the reconstructed Western Interior Seaway. Later fluid infiltration locally lowered the δ18O of carbonates even further, based on the O-isotope compositions of veins related to younger compressional deformation and to the onset of crustal-scale extension in the Eocene. This progression toward lowered δ18O of the surficial waters is compatible with the retreat of the seaway during emergence of the thrust wedge and Paleogene extension, uplift, and subaerial volcanism.

AB - Finite strain and geochemical variations along strain gradients were used to study cleavage development in carbonates in the Lost River Range, Idaho. Deformation accommodating layer-parallel shear was partitioned into thin deformation zones during folding of Willow Creek anticline. Cleavage intensity is strong to very strong in deformation zones and weak in surrounding rocks. Strain magnitudes range from ēS=0.32 (1:15:0.93:0.73; x, y, z, principal axes of strain) outside, to ēS,=0.64 (1.29:0.80:0.52) inside, deformation zones. We found a positive linear correlation between strain, cleavage development, and negative dilation. Volume loss, at a cubic centimeter scale, ranges from 12 percent to 49 percent. Cleavage selvages are depleted in Ca and 18O and enriched in other elements relative to microlithons and less deformed protolith carbonates. Mass-balance considerations indicate that cleavage was formed by incongruent pressure solution leading to a passive concentration of less soluble components during Ca loss and metasomatic additions of Si, Al, and K to produce authigenic clay minerals in selvages. Data for the Willow Creek locality and elsewhere in the Lost River Range (Davidson and others, 1998), Pioneer Mountains, and the Tendoy Range (Bebout and others, 2001), show that across the Sevier orogen, fluid infiltration was heterogeneous at centimeter-kilometer scales and resulted from positive feedback between deformation and far-traveled surficial fluids. Metasomatic strain softening enhanced deformation zone development, which generated increased permeability as the thrust belt evolved from a porosity-based closed system to a discontinuity-based open system. Increased fluid infiltration and isotopic exchange was associated with volume loss, increasingly prolate strains, and crystallization of clays, to produce the cleavage selvages. Mass transfer was accommodated by diffusion early and advection later in the deformation history. Mesoscopic structures (deformation zones, faults, veins) focused fluid flow and were kinematically related to larger-scale structures (faults, faultrelated folds). The inferred addition of surficial fluids to depths of > 7 kilometers in the thrust belt implies a fluid regime involving significant topographically driven recharge. Deformed whole-rocks and microsamples are lower in δ18O than undeformed samples which have 0- and C-isotope compositions similar to those of marine carbonates. Veins are even lower in δ818OV-SMOW, with minimum values of ∼ +5 permil reflecting penetration of the crust by ocean-derived precipitation with δ18O near to somewhat lower than 0 permil (range of -7.5 to +2.5‰ calculated for H2O in equilibrium with these veins). The inferred penetration, into the thrust belt, of nearshore meteoric waters is consistent with proximity to the reconstructed Western Interior Seaway. Later fluid infiltration locally lowered the δ18O of carbonates even further, based on the O-isotope compositions of veins related to younger compressional deformation and to the onset of crustal-scale extension in the Eocene. This progression toward lowered δ18O of the surficial waters is compatible with the retreat of the seaway during emergence of the thrust wedge and Paleogene extension, uplift, and subaerial volcanism.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=3843063619&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=3843063619&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:3843063619

VL - 304

SP - 333

EP - 369

JO - American Journal of Science

JF - American Journal of Science

SN - 0002-9599

IS - 4

ER -