Content analysis of medical students' seminars: A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking

Yukari Takata, Gerald H. Stein, Kuniyuki Endo, Akiko Arai, Shun Kohsaka, Yuka Kitano, Hitoshi Honda, Hidetaka Kitazono, Hironobu Tokunaga, Yasuharu Tokuda, Mikako Obika, Tomoko Miyoshi, Hitomi Kataoka, Hidekazu Terasawa

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Background: The study of communication skills of Asian medical students during structured Problem-based Learning (PBL) seminars represented a unique opportunity to assess their critical thinking development. This study reports the first application of the health education technology, content analysis (CA), to a Japanese web-based seminar (webinar). Methods. The authors assigned twelve randomly selected medical students from two universities and two clinical instructors to two virtual classrooms for four PBL structured tutoring sessions that were audio-video captured for CA. Both of the instructors were US-trained physicians. This analysis consisted of coding the students' verbal comments into seven types, ranging from trivial to advanced knowledge integration comments that served as a proxy for clinical thinking. Results: The most basic level of verbal simple responses accounted for a majority (85%) of the total students' verbal comments. Only 15% of the students' comments represented more advanced types of critical thinking. The male students responded more than the female students; male students attending University 2 responded more than male students from University 1. The total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the male instructor was 6.9%; total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the female instructor was 19% (p <0.05). Conclusions: This report is the first to describe the application of CA to a multi-university real time audio and video PBL medical student clinical training webinar in two Japanese medical schools. These results are preliminary, mostly limited by a small sample size (n = 12) and limited time frame (four sessions). CA technology has the potential to improve clinical thinking for medical students. This report may stimulate improvements for implementation.

Original languageEnglish
Article number156
JournalBMC Medical Education
Volume13
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 1 2013

Fingerprint

Medical Students
medical student
content analysis
Students
instructor
Problem-Based Learning
student
Reaction Time
video
learning
Thinking
university
Biomedical Technology
female student
communication skills
Proxy
health promotion
Medical Schools
Health Education
coding

Keywords

  • Clinical thinking development
  • Communication measurement
  • Problem-based learning

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Medicine(all)
  • Education

Cite this

Takata, Y., Stein, G. H., Endo, K., Arai, A., Kohsaka, S., Kitano, Y., ... Terasawa, H. (2013). Content analysis of medical students' seminars: A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking. BMC Medical Education, 13(1), [156]. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6920-13-156

Content analysis of medical students' seminars : A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking. / Takata, Yukari; Stein, Gerald H.; Endo, Kuniyuki; Arai, Akiko; Kohsaka, Shun; Kitano, Yuka; Honda, Hitoshi; Kitazono, Hidetaka; Tokunaga, Hironobu; Tokuda, Yasuharu; Obika, Mikako; Miyoshi, Tomoko; Kataoka, Hitomi; Terasawa, Hidekazu.

In: BMC Medical Education, Vol. 13, No. 1, 156, 01.12.2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Takata, Y, Stein, GH, Endo, K, Arai, A, Kohsaka, S, Kitano, Y, Honda, H, Kitazono, H, Tokunaga, H, Tokuda, Y, Obika, M, Miyoshi, T, Kataoka, H & Terasawa, H 2013, 'Content analysis of medical students' seminars: A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking', BMC Medical Education, vol. 13, no. 1, 156. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6920-13-156
Takata, Yukari ; Stein, Gerald H. ; Endo, Kuniyuki ; Arai, Akiko ; Kohsaka, Shun ; Kitano, Yuka ; Honda, Hitoshi ; Kitazono, Hidetaka ; Tokunaga, Hironobu ; Tokuda, Yasuharu ; Obika, Mikako ; Miyoshi, Tomoko ; Kataoka, Hitomi ; Terasawa, Hidekazu. / Content analysis of medical students' seminars : A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking. In: BMC Medical Education. 2013 ; Vol. 13, No. 1.
@article{c388084eef584de39302d5c02e8dc6c4,
title = "Content analysis of medical students' seminars: A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking",
abstract = "Background: The study of communication skills of Asian medical students during structured Problem-based Learning (PBL) seminars represented a unique opportunity to assess their critical thinking development. This study reports the first application of the health education technology, content analysis (CA), to a Japanese web-based seminar (webinar). Methods. The authors assigned twelve randomly selected medical students from two universities and two clinical instructors to two virtual classrooms for four PBL structured tutoring sessions that were audio-video captured for CA. Both of the instructors were US-trained physicians. This analysis consisted of coding the students' verbal comments into seven types, ranging from trivial to advanced knowledge integration comments that served as a proxy for clinical thinking. Results: The most basic level of verbal simple responses accounted for a majority (85{\%}) of the total students' verbal comments. Only 15{\%} of the students' comments represented more advanced types of critical thinking. The male students responded more than the female students; male students attending University 2 responded more than male students from University 1. The total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the male instructor was 6.9{\%}; total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the female instructor was 19{\%} (p <0.05). Conclusions: This report is the first to describe the application of CA to a multi-university real time audio and video PBL medical student clinical training webinar in two Japanese medical schools. These results are preliminary, mostly limited by a small sample size (n = 12) and limited time frame (four sessions). CA technology has the potential to improve clinical thinking for medical students. This report may stimulate improvements for implementation.",
keywords = "Clinical thinking development, Communication measurement, Problem-based learning",
author = "Yukari Takata and Stein, {Gerald H.} and Kuniyuki Endo and Akiko Arai and Shun Kohsaka and Yuka Kitano and Hitoshi Honda and Hidetaka Kitazono and Hironobu Tokunaga and Yasuharu Tokuda and Mikako Obika and Tomoko Miyoshi and Hitomi Kataoka and Hidekazu Terasawa",
year = "2013",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1186/1472-6920-13-156",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
journal = "BMC Medical Education",
issn = "1472-6920",
publisher = "BioMed Central",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Content analysis of medical students' seminars

T2 - A unique method of analyzing clinical thinking

AU - Takata, Yukari

AU - Stein, Gerald H.

AU - Endo, Kuniyuki

AU - Arai, Akiko

AU - Kohsaka, Shun

AU - Kitano, Yuka

AU - Honda, Hitoshi

AU - Kitazono, Hidetaka

AU - Tokunaga, Hironobu

AU - Tokuda, Yasuharu

AU - Obika, Mikako

AU - Miyoshi, Tomoko

AU - Kataoka, Hitomi

AU - Terasawa, Hidekazu

PY - 2013/12/1

Y1 - 2013/12/1

N2 - Background: The study of communication skills of Asian medical students during structured Problem-based Learning (PBL) seminars represented a unique opportunity to assess their critical thinking development. This study reports the first application of the health education technology, content analysis (CA), to a Japanese web-based seminar (webinar). Methods. The authors assigned twelve randomly selected medical students from two universities and two clinical instructors to two virtual classrooms for four PBL structured tutoring sessions that were audio-video captured for CA. Both of the instructors were US-trained physicians. This analysis consisted of coding the students' verbal comments into seven types, ranging from trivial to advanced knowledge integration comments that served as a proxy for clinical thinking. Results: The most basic level of verbal simple responses accounted for a majority (85%) of the total students' verbal comments. Only 15% of the students' comments represented more advanced types of critical thinking. The male students responded more than the female students; male students attending University 2 responded more than male students from University 1. The total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the male instructor was 6.9%; total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the female instructor was 19% (p <0.05). Conclusions: This report is the first to describe the application of CA to a multi-university real time audio and video PBL medical student clinical training webinar in two Japanese medical schools. These results are preliminary, mostly limited by a small sample size (n = 12) and limited time frame (four sessions). CA technology has the potential to improve clinical thinking for medical students. This report may stimulate improvements for implementation.

AB - Background: The study of communication skills of Asian medical students during structured Problem-based Learning (PBL) seminars represented a unique opportunity to assess their critical thinking development. This study reports the first application of the health education technology, content analysis (CA), to a Japanese web-based seminar (webinar). Methods. The authors assigned twelve randomly selected medical students from two universities and two clinical instructors to two virtual classrooms for four PBL structured tutoring sessions that were audio-video captured for CA. Both of the instructors were US-trained physicians. This analysis consisted of coding the students' verbal comments into seven types, ranging from trivial to advanced knowledge integration comments that served as a proxy for clinical thinking. Results: The most basic level of verbal simple responses accounted for a majority (85%) of the total students' verbal comments. Only 15% of the students' comments represented more advanced types of critical thinking. The male students responded more than the female students; male students attending University 2 responded more than male students from University 1. The total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the male instructor was 6.9%; total mean students' verbal response time for the four sessions with the female instructor was 19% (p <0.05). Conclusions: This report is the first to describe the application of CA to a multi-university real time audio and video PBL medical student clinical training webinar in two Japanese medical schools. These results are preliminary, mostly limited by a small sample size (n = 12) and limited time frame (four sessions). CA technology has the potential to improve clinical thinking for medical students. This report may stimulate improvements for implementation.

KW - Clinical thinking development

KW - Communication measurement

KW - Problem-based learning

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84888341121&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84888341121&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1186/1472-6920-13-156

DO - 10.1186/1472-6920-13-156

M3 - Article

C2 - 24289320

AN - SCOPUS:84888341121

VL - 13

JO - BMC Medical Education

JF - BMC Medical Education

SN - 1472-6920

IS - 1

M1 - 156

ER -